Aid groups grade the Gaza peace plan 4 out of 26 and call it a failure, a year on
Five leading aid organisations — the Danish Refugee Council, the Norwegian Refugee Council, Oxfam, Refugees International and Save the Children — have graded the US administration's 20-point Gaza peace plan at 4 out of 26 in a humanitarian scorecard published a year after the plan was launched, down from 5 at the six-month mark. The scorecard gives humanitarian access a zero and civilian protection one point, and says at least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed since the ceasefire was declared. No Israeli or US government response to the scorecard was in the reporting read.

Checking in progress
This story is still being checked. Claims below are published as claims — never dressed as facts — and each one moves only when the evidence earns it.
- Collecting reportsDone
- Grouping the versionsDone
- 3Checking claims3 of 4 claims checked
- 4Human gateStill to come
3 of 4 claims checked so far · step 3 of 4: Checking claims
Key points
- Five aid organisations grade the Gaza peace plan 4 out of 26, down from 5 out of 26 six months ago.
- Humanitarian access scores zero; the scorecard says 49 UN-coordinated aid trucks a day entered in September against a stipulated 600.
- The scorecard says at least 1,650 Palestinians have been killed since the ceasefire declaration — its own figure, not independently verified here.
Show more (1)
- The groups urge the Security Council and the Board of Peace to press for full aid access and ceasefire monitoring.
What happened
The 20-point plan, launched a year ago and endorsed by the UN Security Council in Resolution 2803 on 17 November 2025, set the ceasefire terms for Gaza, including a minimum of 600 UN-coordinated aid trucks a day. The five organisations published a first scorecard on the same measures at the six-month mark in April 2026, grading the plan 5 out of 26.
The new scorecard lands in the same week Israeli forces carried out a ground operation in central Gaza beyond the Yellow Line, which Israel says has now concluded.
What we know / what we don't know yet
What we know
- The scorecard, its authors, its grades and its recommendations, from the organisations' own release.
- That the grade fell from 5 out of 26 in April to 4 out of 26 now, on the organisations' own scoring.
What we don't know yet
- Any Israeli or US government response to the scorecard — none was in the reporting read.
- Independent verification of the scorecard's casualty and territorial-control figures — they are carried as the organisations' figures.
- Whether the Security Council or the Board of Peace will act on the recommendations.
Claim by claim
Show all claims (4)
Why this label: The scorecard, its authors, its 4-out-of-26 grade and the fall from 5 are the organisations' own published assessment, carried in their release and reported by Arab News.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: The zero grade, the 600-truck stipulation and the 49-a-day September average are the scorecard's own figures and grading, stated as the organisations' assessment.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: The casualty, control and displacement figures are the scorecard's own, attributed to it everywhere they appear; they have not been independently verified in this pass, and no Israeli figure for the same period was in the reporting read.
On the ladder: the evidence so far sits low — early, single or social sources. We publish the claim as a claim, never as fact.
Why this label: The recommendations are the scorecard's own, quoted from its release, including the named statements of the five organisations' leaders.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why it matters
The plan's own promises are the yardstick here: a year on, the organisations charged with delivering aid inside Gaza say almost none of them have been met, and they put the shortfall in numbers — 4 of 26, zero for access, 49 trucks against 600 promised. Whether the governments that endorsed the plan answer that grading is now the open question.
Background
Show the background timeline (4)
A ceasefire is declared in Gaza under the 20-point plan.
The UN Security Council endorses the plan in Resolution 2803.
The five organisations' six-month scorecard grades the plan 5 out of 26.
The one-year scorecard grades the plan 4 out of 26 and calls it a failure.
Update history
No silent edits. Every change is written here, with its time.
- Latest
Published in Checking state — checking continues, and claims are labelled as reporting develops. The scorecard and its grades rest on the five organisations' own release; their casualty and control figures are carried as their figures, and no Israeli or US response was in the reporting read.