Germany and Britain reject US criticism of Ukraine's deep strikes on Russia, Pistorius calling it 'quite a stupid thing'
Germany and Britain publicly rejected the Pentagon policy chief Elbridge Colby's criticism of Ukraine's strikes deep inside Russia at Tuesday's Ukraine Defence Contact Group meeting in Brussels. Colby said the strikes have not been effective and have probably hardened Russian resolve; German Defence Minister Boris Pistorius called criticising them “quite a stupid thing”, and Britain's Wes Streeting said the strikes have degraded Putin's war machine.

Key points
- The Pentagon's policy chief said Ukraine's deep strikes don't work and harden Russian resolve.
- Germany's Pistorius called that criticism “quite a stupid thing” in public; Britain's Streeting backed the strikes too.
- The clash was open, at the allies' own coordination meeting in Brussels.
Show more (1)
- Each side's words are carried as its position; neither side's claim about the strikes' effect is settled here.
Watch: the moment itself
Direct video sits at the top of Vozia's evidence ladder — the moment itself, from its owner. Embedded from its home platform; we never download or re-host it.
Video: NATO News · Watch on YouTube
What happened
The disagreement is about the long-range campaign Ukraine has been running against Russian oil infrastructure, warehouses and other targets far behind the front line, alongside Russia's own nightly strikes on Ukrainian cities and power systems. Colby also urged ministers to keep funding the PURL programme, under which allies pay for American weapons for Ukraine.
The same meeting brought new air-defence pledges for Ukraine, including the UK's £240 million package and new PURL contributions, which Vozia covers separately.
Both sides, in their own words
Both sides heard. Neither believed for free. Publishing a side's version is not endorsing it — the claim checks below are where verdicts live.
Side A · The US position (Elbridge Colby)
- Deep strikes “have not been effective in driving an end to the war, nor do they contribute to blunting Russia's advances on the front line.”
- Such strikes, especially on civilian infrastructure such as the Wildberries warehouses, have “probably hardened the Russian public's resolve and the Kremlin's own willingness to escalate.”
- Support should focus on equipment for front-line combat.
Side B · Germany and Britain (Pistorius and Streeting)
- Pistorius: criticising strikes that destroy strategic military targets in Russia is “quite a stupid thing”; the criticism should be of Russia's nightly strikes on Ukraine's energy, water and heating — “kind of terrorism.”
- Streeting: the strikes “helped to degrade Putin's war machine, buying time and saving lives”, and “it's not for us to tell Ukraine how to fight their war.”
Independently verified
4 claims independently verified — listed in the claim-by-claim check below.Not yet verified
Nothing outstanding.What we know / what we don't know yet
What we know
- What each side said, in its own words, at and around the Brussels meeting.
- That the meeting's business — more arms and air defence for Ukraine ahead of winter — went ahead alongside the dispute.
What we don't know yet
- Whether US policy on Ukraine's deep strikes, or on the weapons that enable them, will change after this exchange.
- Any response from Colby or the Pentagon to Pistorius's remarks beyond the meeting.
Claim by claim
Show all claims (4)
Why this label: Colby's own words at NATO headquarters, reported by AP and Reuters; carried as the US position, not as a finding about the strikes' effect.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Pistorius's own words to reporters at the meeting, in both wires' accounts; the deep-strikes question was also put at the meeting's joint press conference, whose transcript NATO published.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Streeting's words as Reuters and AP report them.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Meeting details from Reuters and NATO's own published transcript of the closing press conference.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why it matters
Public disagreement between Washington and Ukraine's two biggest European backers over how Ukraine should fight goes to the heart of the alliance's strategy: whether long-range strikes pressure Russia toward an end to the war, or harden it. The answer shapes what weapons Ukraine is given, and what it is allowed to do with them.
Background
Ukraine builds a long-range strike campaign against Russian oil, logistics and military targets deep inside Russia.
At the Ukraine Defence Contact Group in Brussels, Colby criticises the deep strikes; Pistorius and Streeting reject the criticism in public.
Update history
No silent edits. Every change is written here, with its time.
- Latest
Published — each side's words rest on Reuters and AP reporting of the meeting, with NATO's own press-conference transcript published the same day.