Markets · delayed Markets · delayed · loading…
← Back to all news
Politics United StatesBriefMedia Checked story Published 20 November 2026 · Updated 20 Nov, 04:05 UTC

Judge dismisses most of Trump's $15bn defamation case against the New York Times — a narrowed case proceeds

A federal judge in Tampa has thrown out most of President Donald Trump's $15 billion defamation lawsuit against the New York Times and Penguin Random House, ruling that 27 of the 34 statements Trump challenged cannot be sued over and dismissing in full the claims over a 2024 article about 'The Apprentice'. But Judge Steven Merryday let a narrowed case proceed on seven statements — six from the book 'Lucky Loser' and one from a second Times article — finding the complaint plausibly alleges the authors published complex-crime accusations knowing they lacked a firm basis. The ruling decides nothing about whether any statement was actually false.

The New York Times Building in New York (file photo)
Photo: Ajay Suresh via Wikimedia Commons (CC BY 2.0) · (File photo — not from this event)

Key points

  • 27 of the 34 statements Trump challenged were ruled not actionable, and the claims over the 2024 'Apprentice' article were dismissed in full.
  • A narrowed case proceeds on seven statements — six from the book 'Lucky Loser' and one from a Peter Baker article — with the defendants to answer within 28 days.
  • The judge found the complaint plausibly alleges the authors published complex-crime accusations knowing their basis was thin; he decided nothing about whether any statement was false.
Show more (1)
  • The $15 billion damages claim is unchanged; Trump's team praised the ruling and the Times called the remaining claim baseless.
Your take
Sign in to record your take — it’s free, so one person counts once
Takes sit on a free account, so one person counts once.

What happened

Trump filed the suit in September 2025 seeking at least $15 billion over the Times' and Penguin's reporting of his finances and image. Judge Merryday struck the original 85-page complaint within days for failing the rule requiring a short and plain statement; Thursday's ruling decides the second amended complaint, filed in August 2026. Under the Sullivan standard, a public figure must prove a publisher knew a statement was false or acted with reckless disregard for the truth.

What we know / what we don't know yet

What we know

  • The split itself — what was dismissed, what survives and the judge's reasoning — from the court order, with Reuters and Barron's agreeing.
  • Each side's public reaction, in its own words.

What we don't know yet

  • Whether any surviving statement is actually false, or was published with actual malice — expressly undecided at this stage.
  • Whether either side appeals, settles, or the case reaches a trial — no schedule beyond the 28-day answer deadline was in the reporting read.
§

Claim by claim

4 verified· 0 disputed· 0 not yet verified· 0 corrected
Show all claims (4)
Verified
Judge Steven Merryday of the US District Court in Tampa ruled on Thursday on the defendants' motion to dismiss Trump's second amended complaint. Of the 34 statements Trump challenged, 27 were held not actionable — the order says that even if untrue, and even if published with ill will, none can proceed as a defamation claim under the 'actual malice' standard of New York Times v. Sullivan. Counts III and IV, covering a September 2024 Times article about 'The Apprentice' and the making of Trump's public image, were dismissed in full, and Trump's request to amend his complaint again was denied as futile.

Why this label: The split, the 27-of-34 tally and the full dismissal of the 'Apprentice' article counts are the order's own conclusion, reported the same way by Reuters.

On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.

Verified
Four counts survive — Counts I, II, V and VI — but they now rest on just seven statements: six from 'Lucky Loser', Susanne Craig and Russ Buettner's 2024 book about how Trump inherited and spent his father's fortune, including its accounts of alleged tax-evasion schemes, and one from Peter Baker's October 2024 Times article, a sentence about authorities looking into Trump's ties with the Mafia and penalising him over money-laundering and stock-trade rules. The defendants must answer the surviving counts within 28 days.

Why this label: The surviving counts and the seven statements are listed in the order itself; the 28-day answer deadline is the order's.

On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.

Verified
The judge's reasoning for letting those seven proceed: the complaint plausibly alleges that accusing a named person of planning and perpetrating complex tax crimes required forensic auditing and expert advice the authors knew they did not have — in the order's words, 'they know that they don't know, but they are undeterred', and failing to obtain a qualified opinion was 'a fine example of the purposeful avoidance of the truth'. The ruling is a pleading-stage decision only: it finds no statement false and no defendant liable, and Trump must still prove falsity and actual malice, by clear and convincing evidence, for the case to succeed. The $15 billion damages claim — 'not less than $15 billion' plus punitive damages — is unchanged by the ruling.

Why this label: The quoted phrases are the order's; the damages figure is the complaint's, carried unchanged in the reporting.

On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.

Verified
Trump's legal team praised the ruling, saying the defendants 'will now have to answer for intentionally and maliciously defaming President Trump'. The New York Times said it was 'encouraged to see Judge Merryday's dismissal of almost all claims against us', called the remaining claim baseless and an attack on 'the rights of the free and independent press in this country'. Penguin Random House said it stands by the book and its authors and is confident the case will be fully dismissed.

Why this label: Verified for the fact each side said this; each side's characterisation of the ruling is its own position.

On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.

Why it matters

Both sides can claim a win, and both do — but the shape of the case has changed: a $15 billion suit built on 34 statements now stands on seven, all of them accusations of financial crime. Whether those seven were published with 'actual malice' is now the whole case, and it has not yet been tested against any evidence.

Background

Show the background timeline (4)
  • 'Lucky Loser' is published by Penguin Random House, alongside the Times' 'Apprentice' article (14 September) and Peter Baker's article (20 October) — the three publications the suit challenges.

  • Trump files the defamation suit seeking at least $15 billion; the original complaint is struck days later for its length.

  • The second amended complaint is filed — the version Thursday's ruling decides.

  • Judge Merryday dismisses most of the case and lets a narrowed case proceed on seven statements.

Update history

No silent edits. Every change is written here, with its time.

  • Latest

    Published — the ruling is confirmed against the court order and Reuters' report.

← Back to all news