Pakistan's new-provinces row deepens: Bilawal rejects a referendum, PML-N ministers hit back
Pakistan's ruling coalition partners are arguing in public over whether new provinces should be created and whether a referendum should decide it. PPP chairman Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari told Karachi's Press Club on Tuesday that referendums in Pakistan's history had served undemocratic acts, backed Imran Khan's release and called the 27th Amendment a product of brute majority. Defence Minister Khawaja Asif answered on X that public opinion should sit alongside Parliament's, and that whoever claims equity must come with clean hands.

Checking in progress
This story is still being checked. Claims below are published as claims — never dressed as facts — and each one moves only when the evidence earns it.
- Collecting reportsDone
- Grouping the versionsDone
- Checking claims4 of 4 claims checked
- 4Human gateWe are here
4 of 4 claims checked so far · step 4 of 4: Human gate
Key points
- Bilawal rejected a referendum on new provinces, saying referendums in Pakistan's history served undemocratic acts.
- Khawaja Asif backed taking public opinion alongside Parliament's, and told Bilawal to come with clean hands.
- PML-N ministers say the PPP shares power in three provinces and cannot pose as opposition.
Show more (1)
- The MQM-P's earlier attempt at new units, via the 26th and 27th Amendments, was blocked by the PPP, its leader says.
What happened
Pakistan has four provinces — Punjab, Sindh, Khyber Pakhtunkhwa and Balochistan — and the idea of creating new administrative units has returned to the centre of politics, with the MQM-P pressing for units in Sindh and Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi recommending a referendum to decide the question. The PPP, which governs Sindh, opposes any division of the province that is not carried through the constitutional process.
The exchange is a public row inside the ruling coalition: Bilawal's PPP and Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif's PML-N have governed together since 2022, and the president and the Senate chairperson are both from the PPP.
Both sides, in their own words
Both sides heard. Neither believed for free. Publishing a side's version is not endorsing it — the claim checks below are where verdicts live.
Side A · Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari and the PPP
- That a referendum is the wrong instrument for creating provinces: in Pakistan's history, he said, a referendum has always been carried out for an undemocratic act and never a democratic one.
- That the governance system did not collapse but was made to collapse, and that the 27th Amendment was passed with brute majority.
- That dividing Sindh by force would risk bloodshed in Karachi and Hyderabad, as his remarks were reported by the ministers answering him.
Side B · The PML-N ministers' answer
- That public opinion should be taken into account alongside Parliament's on new provinces — the pinnacle of legitimacy, in Khawaja Asif's words.
- That the PPP, in power in three provinces and holding the presidency and the Senate chair, cannot pose as opposition while sharing government since 2022.
- That the PPP itself blocked the MQM-P's attempt to create new administrative units through the 26th and 27th Amendments.
Independently verified
4 claims independently verified — listed in the claim-by-claim check below.Not yet verified
Nothing outstanding.What we know / what we don't know yet
What we know
- That Bilawal rejected the referendum idea and the PML-N's senior ministers answered him in public on Wednesday — each side's words are on the record.
- That the MQM-P's earlier route to new units, through constitutional amendments, was blocked, on its own leader's account.
What we don't know yet
- Whether a referendum will actually be called — no date or formal proposal has been announced.
- The PML-N's official party position — its leader, Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif, had not spoken on the row in the reporting read.
- Whether the PPP and the PML-N will settle the row inside the coalition or carry it into Parliament.
Claim by claim
Show all claims (4)
Why this label: Bilawal's position in his own words, as reported by Dawn. A principal's own words verify that he said it; what follows from it is a separate question.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Asif's response in his own words, in his X post as reported by Dawn.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Chaudhry's response in his own words. Dawn's report carries the two ministers giving different lengths for the PPP's rule in Sindh — Asif said 18 years, Chaudhry 17 — so no year count is carried as fact here.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why this label: Kamal's account of the earlier amendment attempts is his party's position, stated as such.
On the ladder: a claim earns Verified from primary evidence, or from two independent sources that do not copy each other.
Why it matters
How Pakistan is divided into provinces decides who controls land, water, jobs and development money for more than 240 million people. A referendum route would take the question over Parliament's head; the PPP's resistance, and the PML-N's public answer, test whether the coalition can hold together on the country's most sensitive internal question.
Background
Interior Minister Mohsin Naqvi says the governance system has collapsed and needs a reset, and later recommends a referendum on new administrative units.
Bilawal Bhutto-Zardari addresses the Karachi Press Club, rejecting the referendum and criticising the coalition's record.
Khawaja Asif, Tallal Chaudhry and Mustafa Kamal answer Bilawal in public.
Update history
No silent edits. Every change is written here, with its time.
- Latest
Published in Checking state — both sides' positions rest on their own words as reported by Dawn; whether a referendum is called, and the PML-N's formal party position, are still to come.